THIS IS NOT YR COUNTRY, PART 78 MILLION
Aug. 20th, 2008 10:15 amITEM [via BoingBoing]: A US human-rights worker tells the one about how she was detained by the DHS at JFK when she returned from her holiday. The reason: she’d just come back from a vacation in Syria.
What follows is an amazing first-person account of how “suspicious” people trying to enter the country legally are treated – even if they’re Americans. Key takeaways:
Well, gee, at least she got out of there alive.
And Americans wonder why the people who still don’t hate America try to enter illegally.
To be fair, lots of foreigners (i.e. the ones who aren’t Arabs or Arab-looking) get into the US without being given the third degree. But Cory Doctorow at BoingBoing makes a very good point: “I once got pulled out for secondary screening at the Australian border. They brought my pregnant wife a chair and a glass of water, were friendly and professional and prompt, and never made me feel anything other than welcome. They thoroughly investigated me without ever making me feel like a crook. It took all of 10 minutes. It doesn't have to be this way.”
I agree. I’ve already related my experience with Chinese immigration at Doumen (which, for the record, is the only trouble I’ve ever had getting in and out of China), and I’ve been to countries I thought would be much harder to get into by virtue of being American alone (Vietnam, Cambodia and Laos come to mind) and at worst they’ve been indifferent. Israel has the tightest security I’ve ever seen – no foreigner gets in or out without a full bag search and grilling, and they’ve always been cool to me (though admittedly a US passport might warrant better treatment).
Maybe it’s different for those countries if you hold certain types of passports (in Hong Kong, if yr a single woman with a Thai passport they assume yr a prostitute). That doesn’t make it right. If America really cares about its image problem overseas (and as Leader Of The Free World, it bloody well should) and wants to improve it, this is probably NOT the way to go about it.
Johnny foreigner,
This is dF
What follows is an amazing first-person account of how “suspicious” people trying to enter the country legally are treated – even if they’re Americans. Key takeaways:
I watched as [Paul, a British citizen], over the course of four hours, went from feeling exuberant about his trip to New York to despising the entire country. "I speak the Queen's English," he said to me. "I'm third-generation British. I came to America because I've always wanted to come here, and now they've got me so scared that all I want to do is go home."
I don't know if it's worse for national security – and more embarrassing for Americans – that this is the first experience tourists have of our country, or that some US citizens get treated this way upon entering their own country.
Well, gee, at least she got out of there alive.
And Americans wonder why the people who still don’t hate America try to enter illegally.
To be fair, lots of foreigners (i.e. the ones who aren’t Arabs or Arab-looking) get into the US without being given the third degree. But Cory Doctorow at BoingBoing makes a very good point: “I once got pulled out for secondary screening at the Australian border. They brought my pregnant wife a chair and a glass of water, were friendly and professional and prompt, and never made me feel anything other than welcome. They thoroughly investigated me without ever making me feel like a crook. It took all of 10 minutes. It doesn't have to be this way.”
I agree. I’ve already related my experience with Chinese immigration at Doumen (which, for the record, is the only trouble I’ve ever had getting in and out of China), and I’ve been to countries I thought would be much harder to get into by virtue of being American alone (Vietnam, Cambodia and Laos come to mind) and at worst they’ve been indifferent. Israel has the tightest security I’ve ever seen – no foreigner gets in or out without a full bag search and grilling, and they’ve always been cool to me (though admittedly a US passport might warrant better treatment).
Maybe it’s different for those countries if you hold certain types of passports (in Hong Kong, if yr a single woman with a Thai passport they assume yr a prostitute). That doesn’t make it right. If America really cares about its image problem overseas (and as Leader Of The Free World, it bloody well should) and wants to improve it, this is probably NOT the way to go about it.
Johnny foreigner,
This is dF