ITEM [via
drhoz and
dinopollard ]: Ashley Todd, a McCain-Palin campaign volunteer in Pittsburgh, tells police she was robbed at an ATM by a ”large black man” who began beating her after seeing a John McCain bumper sticker on her car. For good measure he carved a backwards letter "B" in her cheek. “B” for “Barack”, she said.
Turns out she made the entire thing up, and the “B” was self-inflicted. She has a history of mental problems, they say.
Now, I know people are tempted to paint with a broad brush here and say, “O those insane Republicans!” But that wouldn’t be fair. Sure, every conservative blog on the planet initially believed every word of it (because Matt Drudge broke the story, and Matt is never, EVER wrong), but as details emerged even Michelle Malkin was saying, “Well, now wait just a minute here ...” (even though she went on to claim that actually liberals do this kind of stuff, like, all the time).
Besides, it’s not like young Republicans habitually beat themselves up and then claim they were attacked by Liberals. It only happens like twice every election cycle.
Still, the real story here is how several news organizations reported it as fact without checking up on it. CNN – which didn’t report the story initially and frankly is acting all smug about it – has a surprisingly good summary of this. Notice Hugh Hewiitt at the end talking bullshit.
It’s also worth mentioning that while I don’t for one moment believe McCain would have personally approved something like this, McCain’s spokesperson in Pennsylvania jumped all over the story and gave a more incendiary version of what happened than even Todd did.
Oops!
KDKA, the TV station that got the quotes, has since removed them from its web site, but Talking Points Memo still has them, if yr interested.
Anyway, the real crime here is not the hoax itself, but that it was exploited in the name of sensationalism, race baiting and/or political gain.
The weirdest response, incidentally, came from John Moody, executive VP of Fox News:
Sure. Because for all you know, it was Obama who ordered the hit.
Of course, Moody also said, “If the incident turns out to be a hoax, Senator McCain’s quest for the presidency is over, forever linked to race-baiting.”
Well, gosh, I wonder whose fault that is?
Stop the press,
This is dF
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
Turns out she made the entire thing up, and the “B” was self-inflicted. She has a history of mental problems, they say.
Now, I know people are tempted to paint with a broad brush here and say, “O those insane Republicans!” But that wouldn’t be fair. Sure, every conservative blog on the planet initially believed every word of it (because Matt Drudge broke the story, and Matt is never, EVER wrong), but as details emerged even Michelle Malkin was saying, “Well, now wait just a minute here ...” (even though she went on to claim that actually liberals do this kind of stuff, like, all the time).
Besides, it’s not like young Republicans habitually beat themselves up and then claim they were attacked by Liberals. It only happens like twice every election cycle.
Still, the real story here is how several news organizations reported it as fact without checking up on it. CNN – which didn’t report the story initially and frankly is acting all smug about it – has a surprisingly good summary of this. Notice Hugh Hewiitt at the end talking bullshit.
It’s also worth mentioning that while I don’t for one moment believe McCain would have personally approved something like this, McCain’s spokesperson in Pennsylvania jumped all over the story and gave a more incendiary version of what happened than even Todd did.
Oops!
KDKA, the TV station that got the quotes, has since removed them from its web site, but Talking Points Memo still has them, if yr interested.
Anyway, the real crime here is not the hoax itself, but that it was exploited in the name of sensationalism, race baiting and/or political gain.
The weirdest response, incidentally, came from John Moody, executive VP of Fox News:
If Ms. Todd’s allegations are proven accurate, some voters may revisit their support for Senator Obama, not because they are racists (with due respect to Rep. John Murtha), but because they suddenly feel they do not know enough about the Democratic nominee.
Sure. Because for all you know, it was Obama who ordered the hit.
Of course, Moody also said, “If the incident turns out to be a hoax, Senator McCain’s quest for the presidency is over, forever linked to race-baiting.”
Well, gosh, I wonder whose fault that is?
Stop the press,
This is dF