If the Internet needs anything, it’s more amateur movie reviews. So I should probably disclose that I saw Terminator Salvation over the weekend.
And ... well ...
I should start by saying that I used to have the first Terminator movie on video, and it’s a slightly dated but otherwise gem of an action film (as is almost any movie with Lance Henrikson and a Dick Miller cameo). T2 was a great extension of the premise and had a lot to say about humanity amidst the mayhem. Then we had T3, which was essentially an inferior rehash of T2, but with a suitably grim ending.
Terminator Salvation works in terms of breaking from the old formula (apart from the traditional climatic fight in an industrial factory), but it tries too hard to tie itself to the first batch (see: the traditional climatic fight in an industrial factory, among other things).
The story of Marcus (while not the most original idea – but then neither was the first film – just ask Harlan Ellison) is a nice twist and a potentially good story, but the actual storytelling process is sloppy. It does seem as though they ended up editing out half the dialogue (the half that actually explains what’s going on or why these people are doing what they’re doing) to make room for more action pieces (some of which are great, others not so much).
And frankly, Skynet’s Big Clever Plan to kill John Connor this time is just silly. At least as it’s presented in the final edit.
And speaking of John Connor, I think a lot more could have been done to build up his character as an inspiring Resistance leader. Which isn’t Christian Bale’s fault – he’s pretty good, but Connor was originally supposed to be a smaller role in the film – on this evidence, they made his role bigger without actually writing anything else for him to do or say.
So as cliche as it is to say it, there’s a good film in here somewhere. But as usual, someone buried it under a bunch of explosions.
He’ll be back,
This is dF
And ... well ...
I should start by saying that I used to have the first Terminator movie on video, and it’s a slightly dated but otherwise gem of an action film (as is almost any movie with Lance Henrikson and a Dick Miller cameo). T2 was a great extension of the premise and had a lot to say about humanity amidst the mayhem. Then we had T3, which was essentially an inferior rehash of T2, but with a suitably grim ending.
Terminator Salvation works in terms of breaking from the old formula (apart from the traditional climatic fight in an industrial factory), but it tries too hard to tie itself to the first batch (see: the traditional climatic fight in an industrial factory, among other things).
The story of Marcus (while not the most original idea – but then neither was the first film – just ask Harlan Ellison) is a nice twist and a potentially good story, but the actual storytelling process is sloppy. It does seem as though they ended up editing out half the dialogue (the half that actually explains what’s going on or why these people are doing what they’re doing) to make room for more action pieces (some of which are great, others not so much).
And frankly, Skynet’s Big Clever Plan to kill John Connor this time is just silly. At least as it’s presented in the final edit.
And speaking of John Connor, I think a lot more could have been done to build up his character as an inspiring Resistance leader. Which isn’t Christian Bale’s fault – he’s pretty good, but Connor was originally supposed to be a smaller role in the film – on this evidence, they made his role bigger without actually writing anything else for him to do or say.
So as cliche as it is to say it, there’s a good film in here somewhere. But as usual, someone buried it under a bunch of explosions.
He’ll be back,
This is dF